Showing posts with label RELIGION. Show all posts
Showing posts with label RELIGION. Show all posts

Thursday, August 18, 2011

Blasphemy: A UN-guaranteed human right !?

GMA NEWS:

The Philippines is bound by a United Nations (UN) covenant “upholding blasphemy" as a human right, an advocacy group member said Sunday.

Garrick Bercero, a member of the group Filipino Freethinkers, pointed this out amid the furor caused by the Poleteismo artwork that allegedly offended Christianity.

In its General Comment (GC) No. 34 on Article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), the UN Human Rights Committee (UNHRC) “affirms the superiority of the right to free speech over the so-called right against blasphemy," said Bercero in a statement on the group’s website.

Article 19 of the ICCPR provides for the freedom of expression as a basic human right recognized by the law of nations. Comments of the UNHRC are considered as a source of international law under Article 38 of the Statute of the International Court of Justice, being "teachings of the most highly qualified publicists."

“Prohibitions of displays of lack of respect for a religion or other belief system, including blasphemy laws, are incompatible with the Covenant," the UNHRC said in paragraph 48 of its comment.

On its website, Filipino Freethinkers described itself as an organization of atheists and “freethinkers" in the Philippines working for a secular Filipino society by promoting reason and science.

Requiring state parties to guarantee freedom of expression, the ICCPR “embraces even expression that may be regarded as deeply offensive," though subject to certain limitations, the group said.

Independently accessed by GMA News Online, GC No. 34 was adopted by the UNHRC during its 102nd session from July 11 to 29.

UN also passed resolutions vs defamation of religions

The latest stand of the United Nations on blasphemy is not without limits, considering previous resolutions have been passed not only by the 18 “eminent legal jurists" of the UN Committee Human Rights (UNCHR) but even by the General Assembly, which is the UN’s highest authoritative body.

The UN became alarmed at the intensification of the campaign of defamation of religions and the religious profiling of Muslim minorities, in the aftermath of the tragic events of Sept. 11, 2001.

Several resolutions bearing the same title “Combating defamation of religions" were passed by the Committee’s precursor body, the Human Rights Commission (HRC), beginning 2001 until 2005. Eventually, the UN General Assembly itself passed a resolution with that title in 2005, with 101 states voting in favor, 53 voting against, and 20 abstaining. The Philippines voted in favor.

In March 2006, the HRC became the UNHRC. The UNHRC approved a resolution titled “Combating Defamation of Religions," and submitted it to the General Assembly that passed it after voting. The Philippines again voted for the resolution. (Continue reading here.)

The Philippines “is legally bound by international law to follow GC 34" as one of its signatories and ratifiers, said the Filipino Freethinkers.

“With General Comment No. 34, the Philippine government may be compelled to repeal all the repressive and retrograde blasphemy laws we have in our books that the clerico-fascists keep dusting off and pulling out whenever society dares to go against their medieval aspirations," Bercero said.

On Thursday, Catholic lawyers filed a complaint against officials of the Cultural Center of the Philippines for allegedly violating a pre-war law prohibiting exhibits that offend religion. Also named respondent was Mideo Cruz, the artist behind Poleteismo.

GMA News Online was still trying to reach the involved lawyers to comment on the Filipino Freethinkers’ statement as of posting time.

In a Facebook message to GMA News Online, Karen Flores, who resigned as head of CCP Visual Arts division over the Poleteismo furor, said UNHRC’s GC 34, as well as readings on freedom of expression as a constitutional guarantee, “affirms that the right to free speech could not be superseded by the right to claim blasphemy against other beliefs."

“Hopefully, this would help liberate minds against the threat to curtail the development of the arts and how we could be more educated about it with respect to the diversity of Philippine culture," said Flores, who also shared the Filipino Freethinkers post on her Facebook page.

She added that GC 34 is “related to everything, not just to the exhibit."

“This current issue has on one hand promoted debate and exchange of views on the rights and responsibilities of both secular and religious groups; yet on the other, it can push us to the brink of chaos, where the harming of artists, the destruction of art and the resignation of the CCP Board become justifiable and ‘understandable’ due to accusations of blasphemy and offense to religion," Flores explained.

Prohibited speech

While upholding the right to freedom of expression, the ICCPR, however, may restrict certain forms of speech that goes against the “respect of the rights or reputations of others" and “the protection of national security or of public order, or of public health and morals."

Entered into force in 1976, the ICCPR also prohibits “any advocacy of national, racial, or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility, or violence."

“The right to free speech is not absolute, yes, but it is abridged only by the risk of actual harm. Offense does not constitute real harm, according to our current understanding of the word," Bercero explained.

“Certainly, there was no incitement of violence in Cruz’s piece against any person," the group member said, noting that Cruz and CCP board members have themselves received death threats. — KBK/LBG/MRT, GMA News


BACK TO KAPUSO ONLINE HOMEPAGE and THE KAPUSO ONLINE AWARDS - A Viewer's Choice Special: CLICK HERE TO VOTE


Information Courtesy of GMA News

http://www.gmanews.tv/story/229410/nation/blasphemy-a-un-guaranteed-human-right-phl-group-says

 If You Like This Kapuso Post, Click Here To Subscribe Via Email

Blasphemy: A UN-guaranteed human right !?

GMA NEWS:

The Philippines is bound by a United Nations (UN) covenant “upholding blasphemy" as a human right, an advocacy group member said Sunday.

Garrick Bercero, a member of the group Filipino Freethinkers, pointed this out amid the furor caused by the Poleteismo artwork that allegedly offended Christianity.

In its General Comment (GC) No. 34 on Article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), the UN Human Rights Committee (UNHRC) “affirms the superiority of the right to free speech over the so-called right against blasphemy," said Bercero in a statement on the group’s website.

Article 19 of the ICCPR provides for the freedom of expression as a basic human right recognized by the law of nations. Comments of the UNHRC are considered as a source of international law under Article 38 of the Statute of the International Court of Justice, being "teachings of the most highly qualified publicists."

“Prohibitions of displays of lack of respect for a religion or other belief system, including blasphemy laws, are incompatible with the Covenant," the UNHRC said in paragraph 48 of its comment.

On its website, Filipino Freethinkers described itself as an organization of atheists and “freethinkers" in the Philippines working for a secular Filipino society by promoting reason and science.

Requiring state parties to guarantee freedom of expression, the ICCPR “embraces even expression that may be regarded as deeply offensive," though subject to certain limitations, the group said.

Independently accessed by GMA News Online, GC No. 34 was adopted by the UNHRC during its 102nd session from July 11 to 29.

UN also passed resolutions vs defamation of religions

The latest stand of the United Nations on blasphemy is not without limits, considering previous resolutions have been passed not only by the 18 “eminent legal jurists" of the UN Committee Human Rights (UNCHR) but even by the General Assembly, which is the UN’s highest authoritative body.

The UN became alarmed at the intensification of the campaign of defamation of religions and the religious profiling of Muslim minorities, in the aftermath of the tragic events of Sept. 11, 2001.

Several resolutions bearing the same title “Combating defamation of religions" were passed by the Committee’s precursor body, the Human Rights Commission (HRC), beginning 2001 until 2005. Eventually, the UN General Assembly itself passed a resolution with that title in 2005, with 101 states voting in favor, 53 voting against, and 20 abstaining. The Philippines voted in favor.

In March 2006, the HRC became the UNHRC. The UNHRC approved a resolution titled “Combating Defamation of Religions," and submitted it to the General Assembly that passed it after voting. The Philippines again voted for the resolution. (Continue reading here.)

The Philippines “is legally bound by international law to follow GC 34" as one of its signatories and ratifiers, said the Filipino Freethinkers.

“With General Comment No. 34, the Philippine government may be compelled to repeal all the repressive and retrograde blasphemy laws we have in our books that the clerico-fascists keep dusting off and pulling out whenever society dares to go against their medieval aspirations," Bercero said.

On Thursday, Catholic lawyers filed a complaint against officials of the Cultural Center of the Philippines for allegedly violating a pre-war law prohibiting exhibits that offend religion. Also named respondent was Mideo Cruz, the artist behind Poleteismo.

GMA News Online was still trying to reach the involved lawyers to comment on the Filipino Freethinkers’ statement as of posting time.

In a Facebook message to GMA News Online, Karen Flores, who resigned as head of CCP Visual Arts division over the Poleteismo furor, said UNHRC’s GC 34, as well as readings on freedom of expression as a constitutional guarantee, “affirms that the right to free speech could not be superseded by the right to claim blasphemy against other beliefs."

“Hopefully, this would help liberate minds against the threat to curtail the development of the arts and how we could be more educated about it with respect to the diversity of Philippine culture," said Flores, who also shared the Filipino Freethinkers post on her Facebook page.

She added that GC 34 is “related to everything, not just to the exhibit."

“This current issue has on one hand promoted debate and exchange of views on the rights and responsibilities of both secular and religious groups; yet on the other, it can push us to the brink of chaos, where the harming of artists, the destruction of art and the resignation of the CCP Board become justifiable and ‘understandable’ due to accusations of blasphemy and offense to religion," Flores explained.

Prohibited speech

While upholding the right to freedom of expression, the ICCPR, however, may restrict certain forms of speech that goes against the “respect of the rights or reputations of others" and “the protection of national security or of public order, or of public health and morals."

Entered into force in 1976, the ICCPR also prohibits “any advocacy of national, racial, or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility, or violence."

“The right to free speech is not absolute, yes, but it is abridged only by the risk of actual harm. Offense does not constitute real harm, according to our current understanding of the word," Bercero explained.

“Certainly, there was no incitement of violence in Cruz’s piece against any person," the group member said, noting that Cruz and CCP board members have themselves received death threats. — KBK/LBG/MRT, GMA News


BACK TO KAPUSO ONLINE HOMEPAGE and THE KAPUSO ONLINE AWARDS - A Viewer's Choice Special: CLICK HERE TO VOTE


Information Courtesy of GMA News

http://www.gmanews.tv/story/229410/nation/blasphemy-a-un-guaranteed-human-right-phl-group-says

 If You Like This Kapuso Post, Click Here To Subscribe Via Email

Wednesday, August 17, 2011

Kulo Controversy: Legal experts say Mideo Cruz, CCP did not violate law

MB:

Some legal experts have come to the defense of controversial artist Mideo Cruz and the Cultural Center of the Philippines (CCP), saying they did not violate any law when the former’s collection of art works titled “Poleitismo” was allowed to go on exhibit recently.

Atty. Florin Hilbay of UP Law argued that "the right of Cruz to express himself through ‘Poleitismo’ is recognized by the constitution. It was not as if the CCP exerted extra effort to offend the feelings of subscribers to the Catholic faith."

This was also shared by another colleague at UP Law, Dean Raul Pangalangan.

“Cruz’s work, shocking as it may be, will fall within that protective clause,” Dean Pangalangan said on “24 Oras,” Aug. 16.

"The artist in question is...entitled to the protection of speech clause,” he said on “TV Patrol.”

Prof. Cecilia dela Paz, Head of University of the Philippines – Diliman’s Art Studies Department feels that there is a need for better understanding of the situation.

“It may violate and offend the community and common standards of morality but it would be more protective for us to bring the discussion in a well-informed manner,” she said.

But Sen. Jinggoy, who is tasked to investigate on the controversial art work, hears nothing of it. He is pushing for the CCP board members to resign.

"Yung call ko na magresign ‘yung mga board members because of their insensitivity to the feelings of the Catholic religion,” Sen. Estrada explained.

CCP Chairman Emily Abrera, meanwhile, believes that it should not be Mideo who should bear the brunt of public ire.

“It is not Mideo who has to [deface] the face of Christ but his opinion that our own ways have defaced Christ. The way we have, you know pursued material things and so on, we, by our own actions, have defaced God,” she said.

Abrera explained her take on Mideo’s art.

"I did not take it as his comment against religion. I took it as his comment to society, about how society has treated the different things that we idolize.”

Abrera stood her ground for her decision not to resign amid the controversy despite call by Senator Estrada for the CCP to leave their post.

“I said no. I meant it in all modesty, in all humility. I recognize my responsibility in this case,” she said.

For National Artist for Sculpture Abdulmari Imao, however, Mideo is at fault.

"Ang pagkakamali nu’ng artist (Mideo), hindi niya binigyan ng limit ‘yung kanyang imagination...”

And naturally, from the clergy’s point of view, Miedo committed a sin with his art.

"Look at the picture and there is violence done. A picture has to be considered very sacred. With any other picture, I will be a little bit more understanding. Never with a picture of God,” Cebu Archbishop Jose Palma said.

"The picture of Jesus is not just any picture. He is the picture of God. Nothing like that should be repeated again,” he said on “TV Patrol” that same evening.

For National Artist for Literature F. Sionil Jose, the “artist is immature and juvenile in his attempt to express his views.”

Mideo did not attend the senate hearing and, instead, issued a statement to “24 Oras.”

“Sa isang statement sinabi naman ni Cruz na kaya hindi siya dumalo sa pagdinig ay dahil hindi naman ang kanyang art ang naging paksa

doon kundi ang freedom of expression. Pero muli, humingi siya ng paumanhin sa mga nasaktan dahil sa kanyang obra,” Mel Tiangco reported.


BACK TO KAPUSO ONLINE HOMEPAGE and THE KAPUSO ONLINE AWARDS - A Viewer's Choice Special: CLICK HERE TO VOTE


Information Courtesy of MB \ ALEX VALENTIN BROSAS

http://mb.com.ph/articles/330992/legal-experts-say-mideo-cruz-ccp-did-not-violate-law

 If You Like This Kapuso Post, Click Here To Subscribe Via Email

Kulo Controversy: Legal experts say Mideo Cruz, CCP did not violate law

MB:

Some legal experts have come to the defense of controversial artist Mideo Cruz and the Cultural Center of the Philippines (CCP), saying they did not violate any law when the former’s collection of art works titled “Poleitismo” was allowed to go on exhibit recently.

Atty. Florin Hilbay of UP Law argued that "the right of Cruz to express himself through ‘Poleitismo’ is recognized by the constitution. It was not as if the CCP exerted extra effort to offend the feelings of subscribers to the Catholic faith."

This was also shared by another colleague at UP Law, Dean Raul Pangalangan.

“Cruz’s work, shocking as it may be, will fall within that protective clause,” Dean Pangalangan said on “24 Oras,” Aug. 16.

"The artist in question is...entitled to the protection of speech clause,” he said on “TV Patrol.”

Prof. Cecilia dela Paz, Head of University of the Philippines – Diliman’s Art Studies Department feels that there is a need for better understanding of the situation.

“It may violate and offend the community and common standards of morality but it would be more protective for us to bring the discussion in a well-informed manner,” she said.

But Sen. Jinggoy, who is tasked to investigate on the controversial art work, hears nothing of it. He is pushing for the CCP board members to resign.

"Yung call ko na magresign ‘yung mga board members because of their insensitivity to the feelings of the Catholic religion,” Sen. Estrada explained.

CCP Chairman Emily Abrera, meanwhile, believes that it should not be Mideo who should bear the brunt of public ire.

“It is not Mideo who has to [deface] the face of Christ but his opinion that our own ways have defaced Christ. The way we have, you know pursued material things and so on, we, by our own actions, have defaced God,” she said.

Abrera explained her take on Mideo’s art.

"I did not take it as his comment against religion. I took it as his comment to society, about how society has treated the different things that we idolize.”

Abrera stood her ground for her decision not to resign amid the controversy despite call by Senator Estrada for the CCP to leave their post.

“I said no. I meant it in all modesty, in all humility. I recognize my responsibility in this case,” she said.

For National Artist for Sculpture Abdulmari Imao, however, Mideo is at fault.

"Ang pagkakamali nu’ng artist (Mideo), hindi niya binigyan ng limit ‘yung kanyang imagination...”

And naturally, from the clergy’s point of view, Miedo committed a sin with his art.

"Look at the picture and there is violence done. A picture has to be considered very sacred. With any other picture, I will be a little bit more understanding. Never with a picture of God,” Cebu Archbishop Jose Palma said.

"The picture of Jesus is not just any picture. He is the picture of God. Nothing like that should be repeated again,” he said on “TV Patrol” that same evening.

For National Artist for Literature F. Sionil Jose, the “artist is immature and juvenile in his attempt to express his views.”

Mideo did not attend the senate hearing and, instead, issued a statement to “24 Oras.”

“Sa isang statement sinabi naman ni Cruz na kaya hindi siya dumalo sa pagdinig ay dahil hindi naman ang kanyang art ang naging paksa

doon kundi ang freedom of expression. Pero muli, humingi siya ng paumanhin sa mga nasaktan dahil sa kanyang obra,” Mel Tiangco reported.


BACK TO KAPUSO ONLINE HOMEPAGE and THE KAPUSO ONLINE AWARDS - A Viewer's Choice Special: CLICK HERE TO VOTE


Information Courtesy of MB \ ALEX VALENTIN BROSAS

http://mb.com.ph/articles/330992/legal-experts-say-mideo-cruz-ccp-did-not-violate-law

 If You Like This Kapuso Post, Click Here To Subscribe Via Email

Tuesday, August 16, 2011

More religious and lay groups condemn controversial CCP Kulo art installation

MB:

Various quarters continue to condemn the controversial “Kulo” exhibit even after the Cultural Center of the Philippines (CCP) shut it down last Aug. 9.

As an effort to supposedly seek forgiveness from their Creator for what they deem as “blasphemous” art—particularly artist Mideo Cruz's “Poleteismo” installation which depicts several religious images with animals ears, phallic symbols and condoms—more than 200 members of religious and lay groups participated in a reparation mass held Aug. 14, reported “Unang Hirit” on Aug. 15.

A part of the homily by Jojo Zerrudo, Diocese of Cubao, was aired on the same morning show, where he asserted that proper respect should be given to the image of Christ.

"...you think an image of Christ is nothing different from the posters of celebrities? Jesus Christ is the son of the Living God, therefore, it is not right to dishonor his face,” said Zerrudo.

In an interview, Zerrudo said, “Ang bayad-puri ay act of love for God to make up for a lack of love… We should continuously make reparation. This is only a public manifestation.”

Parishioners stressed their reasons for strongly protesting the exhibit.

“There’s a limit to that art. Art is supposed to uplift us… pero itong art na ito ay pababa,” said Nanding Pacheco in an interview aired on “Umagang Kay Ganda,” Aug. 15.

Ang Kapatiran party’s Manolo Dayrit’s concern, meanwhile, is the effect of the controversial exhibit to Filipino culture.

“Ang Filipino culture natin ay parang sinisira nila. ‘Yung tinatawag nating cultural heritage… positive cultural heritage,” said he in the same “TV Patrol” report.

He added, “Kinakailangang magalit tayo, wag na sanang maulit. Ipagdasal natin na magkaron ng pagbabago ng pag-iisip ang mga gumawa niyan.”

Erick Malalang, president of Pro-Life Philippines, urged everyone to reflect, saying, “…we should ask forgiveness from God.”

Pro-Life Philippines is likewise bent on following Ang Kapatiran party’s step of filing a case against Cruz and CCP officials last Aug. 11 before the Office of the Ombudsman.

Cruz and the members of the CCP Board are said to have violated provisions of the Revised Penal Code, Civil Code, Republic Act 6713 or the “Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees” and Presidential Decree 15, which states the CCP mandate, as cited on “Unang Hirit.”

“When you say church, tayong lahat, we are a church. Filipinos who are Christians and Catholics must defend their faith,” said Dayrit in the same “Unang Hirit” report.

Cruz already apologized to the offended parties even as he upheld his artistic philosophy.

"Humihingi ako ng paumanhin sa mga nasaktan. Pero hindi ako ‘yung tao na nagpipinta ng magandang bulaklak o magandang tanawin. Ang mga ginagawa kong proyekto ay mga bagay na susundutin ng kaunti ang ating mga pag-i-isip," said he in an interview on “State of the Nation with Jessica Soho” on Aug. 12.

As for the latest move of the religious and lay groups, Cruz declined to comment.


BACK TO KAPUSO ONLINE HOMEPAGE and THE KAPUSO ONLINE AWARDS - A Viewer's Choice Special: CLICK HERE TO VOTE


Information Courtesy of MB / ROWENA JOY A. SANCHEZ

http://mb.com.ph/articles/330786/more-religious-and-lay-groups-condemn-controversial-ccp-art-installation

 If You Like This Kapuso Post, Click Here To Subscribe Via Email

More religious and lay groups condemn controversial CCP Kulo art installation

MB:

Various quarters continue to condemn the controversial “Kulo” exhibit even after the Cultural Center of the Philippines (CCP) shut it down last Aug. 9.

As an effort to supposedly seek forgiveness from their Creator for what they deem as “blasphemous” art—particularly artist Mideo Cruz's “Poleteismo” installation which depicts several religious images with animals ears, phallic symbols and condoms—more than 200 members of religious and lay groups participated in a reparation mass held Aug. 14, reported “Unang Hirit” on Aug. 15.

A part of the homily by Jojo Zerrudo, Diocese of Cubao, was aired on the same morning show, where he asserted that proper respect should be given to the image of Christ.

"...you think an image of Christ is nothing different from the posters of celebrities? Jesus Christ is the son of the Living God, therefore, it is not right to dishonor his face,” said Zerrudo.

In an interview, Zerrudo said, “Ang bayad-puri ay act of love for God to make up for a lack of love… We should continuously make reparation. This is only a public manifestation.”

Parishioners stressed their reasons for strongly protesting the exhibit.

“There’s a limit to that art. Art is supposed to uplift us… pero itong art na ito ay pababa,” said Nanding Pacheco in an interview aired on “Umagang Kay Ganda,” Aug. 15.

Ang Kapatiran party’s Manolo Dayrit’s concern, meanwhile, is the effect of the controversial exhibit to Filipino culture.

“Ang Filipino culture natin ay parang sinisira nila. ‘Yung tinatawag nating cultural heritage… positive cultural heritage,” said he in the same “TV Patrol” report.

He added, “Kinakailangang magalit tayo, wag na sanang maulit. Ipagdasal natin na magkaron ng pagbabago ng pag-iisip ang mga gumawa niyan.”

Erick Malalang, president of Pro-Life Philippines, urged everyone to reflect, saying, “…we should ask forgiveness from God.”

Pro-Life Philippines is likewise bent on following Ang Kapatiran party’s step of filing a case against Cruz and CCP officials last Aug. 11 before the Office of the Ombudsman.

Cruz and the members of the CCP Board are said to have violated provisions of the Revised Penal Code, Civil Code, Republic Act 6713 or the “Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees” and Presidential Decree 15, which states the CCP mandate, as cited on “Unang Hirit.”

“When you say church, tayong lahat, we are a church. Filipinos who are Christians and Catholics must defend their faith,” said Dayrit in the same “Unang Hirit” report.

Cruz already apologized to the offended parties even as he upheld his artistic philosophy.

"Humihingi ako ng paumanhin sa mga nasaktan. Pero hindi ako ‘yung tao na nagpipinta ng magandang bulaklak o magandang tanawin. Ang mga ginagawa kong proyekto ay mga bagay na susundutin ng kaunti ang ating mga pag-i-isip," said he in an interview on “State of the Nation with Jessica Soho” on Aug. 12.

As for the latest move of the religious and lay groups, Cruz declined to comment.


BACK TO KAPUSO ONLINE HOMEPAGE and THE KAPUSO ONLINE AWARDS - A Viewer's Choice Special: CLICK HERE TO VOTE


Information Courtesy of MB / ROWENA JOY A. SANCHEZ

http://mb.com.ph/articles/330786/more-religious-and-lay-groups-condemn-controversial-ccp-art-installation

 If You Like This Kapuso Post, Click Here To Subscribe Via Email